Cutting Our Defence Budget?

The papers today carried a letter from Ms Hazel Pua of the Reform Party written in reply to MND Minister Mah Bow Tan's op-ed piece some days back defending the affordability of HDB flat. Various very good points were made in the letter to argue that HDB flats are now less affordable, with Minister Mah's assumptions taken part rather cleverly.

That said, I would disagree with part of the following:

The Reform Party is happy to offer some other options for consideration: Cutting the defence budget; reducing the payments made by HDB to the Singapore Land Authority for the purchase of land to build HDB flats; and cutting ministerial salaries.

To my mind, the above statement appears to suggest that our current level of defence spending is unnecessary. But in the absence of a war to test out the adequacy of our military, such a claim is untestable. To draw an analogy from IT, it is like trying to argue whether one's off-site backup system is cost-effective when there had been no data disasters before to quantify the range of possible losses.

I think cutting the defence budget is a terrible idea. As I have maintained throughout my writings on this blog, the world is moving into a period of greater geopolitical risks, driven largely by resource scarcity. Given our dependence on foreign resources for our most basic needs, it is paramount that we have a strong military as a kind of leverage against any hostile foreign intentions. Furthermore, such military force will likely be required to keep our sea lanes open in the face of terrorist threats. Ms Pua and the Reform Party have made the rather common error of thinking that if Singapore is friendly towards other countries, they will reciprocate. I would suggest that they read some of the local language newspapers of our neighbours if they have not seen the vitriol poured out against Singapore on a fairly regular basis.

The Reform Party's letter again shows, in my view, that the coming elections will only be about domestic issues. The bigger storm clouds coming over the horizon are being ignored by all political parties.