Friday, October 15, 2010

Property - Buy What You Can Afford

I saw a Bloomberg article today on the impact of the government's recent property curbs on HDB resale prices. What caught my attention was the case of the civil servant mentioned in the article.

The civil servant, who reportedly was earning about $2,500 a month, paid $405,000 for a 4-room Type S flat in Bishan, inclusive of $50,000 COV. In the article, he sounded somewhat unhappy at having bought at the top of the market just before the new property curbs were announced.

Personally, I found it hard to have any sympathy for his situation. Here's why:

1. Assuming that his fiancée is also earning at the same level as he is, a combined income of around $5,000 is, according to what I feel is financially prudent, too low to afford a flat of over $400K.

2. He overpriced his time very badly. At around the time of his purchase, a similar 4-room flat in Yishun would have cost $100K less than the Bishan one. The different between Bishan and Yishun is 4 MRT stations in terms of travelling. That's an additional 25 mins 1-way of travelling. Is his free time worth that much money? Being a civil servant isn't all that stressful in any case (I should know - I was one before).

3. Wiping out one's savings on property is a bad idea. Choosing a less prestigious location to buy property could have saved him quite a bit of money.

Of course, he has every right to do as he pleases with his money. I just felt that complaining about the negative impact of a government policy change in the press is a bad reflection of one's judgement.

No comments:

Post a Comment